Skip to main content
City Prime Care logoCity Prime Care

HealthcareBy City Prime Care Team

Stool Test or Colonoscopy: Which Colorectal Cancer Screening Is Right for You? Reading the Test Options, the Five Prep Steps and the Sample Screening Calendar

Colorectal cancer screening now starts at 45, and you have more than one choice. Compare stool tests and colonoscopy, learn how each works, how to prepare, what a positive result means, and a sample screening calendar.

Medically reviewed by City Prime Care Administrator9 min read

Illustration of a stool test kit, a calendar, a clipboard and a calm check mark with a gentle digestive tract outline
Table of contents
  1. 1. When to Start, and Who Starts Earlier
  2. 2. The Main Tests Compared
  3. 3. How Often Each Test Is Repeated
  4. 4. How the Stool Tests Work
  5. 5. How Colonoscopy Works, and the Five Prep Steps
  6. 6. What a Positive or Abnormal Result Means
  7. 7. A Sample Screening Calendar
  8. 8. Symptoms to Report, Red Flags, and Booking
  9. Conclusion
  10. Frequently Asked Questions
  11. See a Doctor in Elmhurst or Chinatown

Colorectal cancer is one of the most preventable cancers, because screening can find small growths called polyps before they turn cancerous, and can find cancer early when treatment works best. Yet many adults put screening off, often because they think the only option is a colonoscopy. In fact there are several tests, and the best one is the one you will actually do, on schedule.

This guide compares the main colorectal cancer screening tests, explains when to start, how each test works, how to prepare, what a positive result means, and gives a sample screening calendar. It draws on the preventive care, men's health, and comprehensive health assessments pages of the City Prime Care website, which say colorectal screening generally begins at 45, using a stool-based test or a colonoscopy by referral, with stool kits handled in the clinic. It is general education, not personal medical advice. You can find the clinic on Google: City Prime Care on Google. See the clinic's preventive care page.

In this article:

  • 1. When to start, and who starts earlier
  • 2. The main tests compared (table)
  • 3. How often each test is repeated (graph)
  • 4. How the stool tests work
  • 5. How colonoscopy works, and the five prep steps
  • 6. What a positive or abnormal result means
  • 7. A sample screening calendar
  • 8. Symptoms to report, red flags, and booking

1. When to Start, and Who Starts Earlier

The clinic's pages say colorectal screening generally begins at 45 for average-risk adults, which matches current U.S. Preventive Services Task Force guidance. Some people should start sooner or be screened more often, and your provider tailors the schedule to your history.

SituationWhat it may change
Average risk, age 45 to 75Screening is recommended; choose a test and stay on schedule
A parent, sibling, or child with colorectal cancer or advanced polypsScreening may need to start earlier, often with colonoscopy; the clinic's page says a close relative with colon cancer can change when screening begins
Inflammatory bowel disease, such as Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitisSurveillance colonoscopy on a specialist's schedule
A prior polyp or colorectal cancerFollow-up colonoscopy as advised
Certain inherited conditionsGenetic counseling and earlier, more frequent testing
Age 76 to 85An individual decision with your clinician, based on health and prior screening

For national guidance, see the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force and the CDC's colorectal cancer screening pages. Our guides on which screenings Elmhurst adults should not skip and men's checkups at every age show where colorectal screening fits.

2. The Main Tests Compared

TestWhat it isHow oftenWhere it is donePros and cons
1. FIT (fecal immunochemical test)A stool sample checked for hidden bloodEvery yearAt home; the clinic says stool kits can be handled in the clinicSimple, no prep, no sedation; a positive result needs a colonoscopy; must be repeated yearly
2. High-sensitivity guaiac test (gFOBT)A stool test for hidden bloodEvery yearAt homeSimilar to FIT with some diet or medicine limits
3. Stool DNA test (such as FIT-DNA)Looks for blood and abnormal DNA in stoolEvery 1 to 3 yearsAt homeMore sensitive for some findings but more false positives; a positive result needs a colonoscopy
4. ColonoscopyA flexible camera examines the whole colon; polyps can be removed during the testEvery 10 years if normalOutside center by referral, as the clinic describesLooks and treats in one test; needs bowel prep, sedation, and a ride home; small risk of complications
5. Flexible sigmoidoscopyExamines the lower colonEvery 5 years, sometimes with a yearly FITBy referralLess commonly used; sees only part of the colon
6. CT colonographyA CT scan of the colonEvery 5 yearsImaging center by referralNo sedation; needs prep; any finding needs colonoscopy

3. How Often Each Test Is Repeated

The graph below is an illustrative picture of how many times each test is typically done over ten years for someone with normal results, using the intervals above. Each block is one test.

TestTests over 10 years (graph)Note
FIT██████████ 10Every year
High-sensitivity guaiac test██████████ 10Every year
Stool DNA test███░░░░░░░ 3 to 10Every 1 to 3 years
Flexible sigmoidoscopy██░░░░░░░░ 2Every 5 years
CT colonography██░░░░░░░░ 2Every 5 years
Colonoscopy█░░░░░░░░░ 1Every 10 years if normal

Fewer tests do not mean a better test. The best choice depends on your risk, preferences, and willingness to repeat the test on schedule.

4. How the Stool Tests Work

A typical home stool test works like this:

  1. Your provider gives you a kit, or the clinic handles the kit, with clear instructions and a return method.
  2. At home, you collect a small stool sample using the tools in the kit, following the label exactly, and avoid urine or toilet water contamination.
  3. You return the sample promptly, as instructed, since samples can degrade.
  4. A laboratory processes it, and your provider reviews the result and tells you what it means.
  5. If the result is negative, you repeat the test on schedule; if positive, you need a colonoscopy to find the cause.

A positive stool test does not mean cancer. Bleeding can come from hemorrhoids, polyps, or other causes. Follow-up colonoscopy is essential, because an unfollowed positive result removes the benefit of screening.

5. How Colonoscopy Works, and the Five Prep Steps

In a colonoscopy, a specialist passes a thin, flexible camera through the rectum to look at the whole colon, usually under sedation, in about 30 to 60 minutes. Polyps are removed during the test, which is how colonoscopy prevents cancer. The clinic says colonoscopies are arranged by referral to outside specialists, and its referral team sends the order and helps with insurance approval; see our guide on when your doctor sends you to a specialist.

The five prep steps, in plain terms:

  1. Choose and schedule: your specialist's office gives the date, time, and instructions, and you arrange a ride home, since sedation affects driving.
  2. Review medicines: tell the office about blood thinners, diabetes medicines, and supplements, and ask which to hold; never stop a medicine without instruction.
  3. Change your diet the day before, usually clear liquids only, as directed.
  4. Take the bowel prep exactly as instructed, often a split dose the evening before and the morning of the test, and keep drinking clear fluids.
  5. Arrive on time with your ID, insurance, and a list of medicines, and plan to rest for the remainder of the day.

Many people find the prep harder than the test. Ask your clinician or the endoscopy center about options to make it easier. For background, see the MedlinePlus colonoscopy page.

6. What a Positive or Abnormal Result Means

ResultWhat it generally meansNext step
Negative stool testNo blood or abnormal DNA found this timeRepeat on schedule
Positive stool testBlood or abnormal DNA found; most positive tests do not turn out to be cancerColonoscopy, promptly
Normal colonoscopyNo polyps or cancer seenRepeat in about 10 years if average risk
Polyps found and removedPolyps are common; some can become cancer if leftFollow-up colonoscopy in a time your specialist sets, based on number, size, and type
Cancer foundEarly-stage colorectal cancer is often highly treatableReferral to a cancer team; your primary care clinic stays involved

The clinic says it follows up on results and stays involved after referrals. See the American Cancer Society's colorectal cancer information for details on stages and treatment.

7. A Sample Screening Calendar

The calendar below is illustrative, not a prescription. It shows two sample paths for an average-risk adult starting at 45.

AgePath A: yearly FITPath B: colonoscopy
45☐ FIT☐ Colonoscopy
46 to 54☐ FIT every year (nine tests)No test if normal
55☐ FITRepeat colonoscopy at 55 if normal
56 to 64☐ FIT every yearNo test if normal
65☐ FITRepeat colonoscopy at 65 if normal
66 to 75☐ FIT every year, or switch to colonoscopyContinue as advised
76 to 85Individual decisionIndividual decision

Ask your clinician which path fits you and write the dates in your calendar. See also our preventive care checklist by age.

8. Symptoms to Report, Red Flags, and Booking

Symptom or situationAction
Blood in the stool, or black, tarry stoolsBook a prompt visit; do not wait for routine screening
A change in bowel habits lasting more than a few weeksBook a visit
Unexplained weight loss, ongoing abdominal pain, or new iron-deficiency anemiaBook a prompt visit; see why you feel tired all the time
Heavy rectal bleeding with dizziness or faintingGo to the ER or call 911
Severe abdominal pain or vomiting after a colonoscopyCall the specialist or go to the ER
Age 45 or older and never screenedBook a visit through the appointment page

Conclusion

The best colorectal screening is the one you will do. A yearly stool test at home or a colonoscopy every ten years both save lives, and a conversation with your clinician can match the choice to your risk and your life.

Contact Us: To ask about colorectal screening, stool test kits, or a colonoscopy referral, reach City Prime Care through our Contact Us page, or find the clinic on Google: City Prime Care on Google. This article is for general information and does not replace personal medical advice. In an emergency, call 911.

Frequently Asked Questions

See a Doctor in Elmhurst or Chinatown

Have a question about your own health? Book a visit at our Elmhurst, Queens clinic or our Chinatown, Manhattan clinic, or explore our primary care services.

We Work With Most Insurance Providers

  • Medicaid
  • 1199SEIU United Healthcare Workers East
  • Fidelis Care
  • Medicare
  • MetroPlus Health Plan
  • EmblemHealth
  • UnitedHealthcare
  • BlueCross BlueShield
  • Healthfirst